Senate panel OKs welfare drug testing

Print Friendly and PDF By: Andy Miller Published: Feb 27, 2012

A Senate health committee Monday approved a bill requiring drug testing for Georgia welfare applicants, after a similar provision for Medicaid enrollees was dropped from the legislation.

Senate Bill 292 passed 9-5, on a party-line vote. Democrats raised questions about the proposal’s constitutionality and its projected cost savings, and challenged the Senate Health and Human Services Committee’s parliamentary procedure prior to the final vote.

The Medicaid rule was dropped from the legislation before the hearing. Federal approval would have been necessary to put it into effect, and last week a state official testified that a federal agency had already denied permission for other states to require drug-testing of Medicaid enrollees.

Separately, a poll released Monday showed that two-thirds of Georgians ‘’strongly support’’ drug testing of Medicaid applicants. The poll, conducted earlier this month by the Schapiro Group, also found that a majority of Democrats support the requirement for Medicaid. The poll results were released by Healthcare Georgia Foundation.

State Sen. John Albers (R-Roswell), the lead sponsor of the bill, said the proposal would save government money on welfare payments, because many applicants would fail the drug test, while others would decline to apply because of the drug-testing requirement.

Albers said the bill would create a level playing field, because some Georgians are already required by their employers to take drug tests. The goal, he said, ‘’is to get people clean . . . and make sure any tax dollars are going to the right purposes.’’

Democrats critical of the bill pointed out that a similar law in Florida has been placed on hold by a federal judge, who questioned whether it violates the Fourth Amendment.

Albers said he has consulted with the offices of the attorneys general in both Florida and Georgia, and with the Heritage Foundation, to create a bill that he believes will pass constitutional muster.

And he said Florida had saved $1.8 million in the first quarter when the welfare drug-testing law was in effect. A new financial analysis of the Georgia bill indicated the state would save money, too, he said.

Under the legislation, welfare applicants would be required to pay for their drug tests, but would be reimbursed if the results were negative.

Democratic Sen. Nan Orrock of Atlanta questioned one of the assumptions that the financial analysis made: that Medicaid would pay for the welfare applicants’ drug tests.

An official with the Department of Community Health, when asked about the payment issue, said Medicaid would probably not pay for the test – and that the state would have to get federal permission to do so.

The discussion of the bill turned contentious before the vote. Orrock, after raising a number of questions on the bill, sought to make a motion, but was denied the opportunity by committee Chairman Renee Unterman (R-Buford). Senate Minority Leader Steve Henson (D-Tucker) took strong exception to that ruling, calling Unterman’s action “outrageous.”

After the hearing, Orrock said that if the bill is ultimately approved, ”the state will surely be sued.’’

“This bill does not meet the smell test,’’ she said, citing the judge’s ruling in Florida. She said the legislation is a Republican effort to “bash poor people.’’

“It will do real damage to real people,’’ Orrock said.

 

Enjoy Georgia Health News? Sign up for free Email Alerts or follow us on Facebook or Twitter

Help support our nonprofit journalism -- your gift is tax deductible!

  • Concerned tax payer

    Is the drug testing a one-time thing? If the Bill passes and is overturned, are the States liable costing perhaps millions? What effect will this be on the children of the denied person? Will there be still more corruption/pay offs to health care facilities who are doing drug testing? Are laws being made to fine/jail time for those facilities/persons involved in corruption? I believe there should be some kind of testing but there are too many questions not answered and the States know this. They are not going to be upheld.

  • Pingback: Drug testing for welfare? Are you kidding me? - Page 13

Sponsorships



University of Georgia College of Public Health Logo





















(Click on the logo for more information about our sponsors.)





Foundation Support for GHN:

Healthcare Georgia Foundation
Kaiser Permanente
Reynolds Charitable Fund
Georgia Health Foundation